Let's take a little pause in my Spain adventure to return to the states and talk about New Jersey Wine! Hey wait, don't go! Don't go! I know, you already think you know that NJ wines suck, they are all sweet hybrid grapes and poor winemaking skills to boot. But what if I told you that New Jersey is making some of the most stunning wines, from vinifera and excellent winemaking talent, I have ever tasted?
Just like New Mexico, struggling against the old ideas of a long ago past where, yes the wines did suck. They too find that no one wants to update their perception of what the wines of the region are like today. That's where I come in... literally. My friend and International Wine Competition comrade, Sharyn Kervyn, decided to take matters into her own hands on behalf off these struggling producers and invite serious, extremely respected wine experts to come in from Canada, the UK, Italy, Ireland and across the USA to assess the wines of NJ. I guess she could now list me as Spain, wow, that's weird. Now this wasn't a competition, this was a showcase. It was supported by a group of wineries that are using 100% New Jersey fruit to be able to showcase their wines to a powerhouse of 12 judges in order to get real, not sugarcoated, feedback. They asked for detailed reports on not what they are doing right, but more importantly, what they are doing wrong. That is one hell of a bold move NJ wineries! It was immediately clear that this group was dedicated to the idea of bettering their wines until are respected by the wine world.
I absolutely LOVED this ballsy move and was 100% on board the minute Sharyn called me. Anyone willing to ask this level of wine judge to come critique your wines and honestly welcome feedback, is pretty rare. Scott Donnini from Auburn Road Vineyard & Winery summed it up beautifully "good feedback and positive reviews are great, but it is actually more valuable to us to tell us what is wrong with some of them or what we could be doing better. That is where we really learn."
With a Master Certificate in Wine Faults, judging experience at prestigious competitions in 7 countries and a gift for pinpointing what is in the glass, I did not take this invitation to be honest lightly. Now keep in mind, we don't want to make anyone cry or give up winemaking. Our goal is constructive criticism. On the other hand, you are asking expert level judges, most of us also educators and journalists, to give you the low down and dirty on your wines. Yikes!
Upon arrival to New Jersey, the City of Camden and the Terroir New Jersey Wine Showcase sponsors really rolled out the red carpet for us. We were treated to wonderful dinners, winery tours, tasty lunches and great rooms at the Spring Hill Suites. Some nay sayers in the NJ community read this as "paying for ratings", believe me, we were not paid. In a show of respect, having travelled from all across the world, it is customary to put judges up and feed them. We all usually fetch a good wage when paid for our expertise, along with airfare, lodging and meals to be included. No one could afford to pay the 12 of us to show up to an event and pay each of our bills. This was done as our favor to the wineries brave enough and determined enough to ask us there.
I do have to rave a bit about the food before getting to the wine. The brick oven fired pizza and lamb chops at Sharrott Winery for our welcome dinner were to die for, the lovely pass around apps and epic view of The Boathouse was incredible, the delicious flatbread lunch and apps at Auburn Road Winery were sensational, and a jaw dropping 6 course wine dinner at Wanda's was over the top excellence.
A quick aside (is she ever going to talk about the wine??? geez!). Wanda's Restaurant is a beautiful, cozy restaurant located in Haddonfield, NJ. If you know that name, then you are my people! Haddenfield is the name of the town from the horror movie franchise Halloween. I get that I sound like a total dork sharing that I excitedly took pictures of the welcome sign as we drove by it on the way to dinner, but that is because my daughter is a horror film buff and I had to text her the photo. She is also a film student in college who just happens to have made a horror short film (recently an official selection at an all women's international film fest) and finished her first feature length horror film. I also happened to be in the car at the time with my daughter's mentor, Emmanuel Kervyn, a famous European horror director (married to Sharyn) and he was very encouraging of this behavior.
OK, finally let's talk New Jersey wines! Honestly I was shocked, we all were. Very few wines we tasted were flawed and those that were, were mostly facing volatile acidity issues, a manageable problem. The informal judges "rating" system we used was the glass/ bottle/ won't share concept. Many of the wines we tasted were good, meaning they could use a little work, but you'd finish the glass. Most of the wines were very good showing varietal character, complexity and if it was a hybrid, restraint. These wines fall into the level that you would buy a bottle after tasting it. And a surprising amount of wines we tasted fell into the exceptional category which is to say that the wine is wonderful and not only would we buy a bottle, we probably wouldn't share it with just anyone that came to dinner. The 12 of us eagerly shared notes at the end of the day, assessing the over all imprint of the tasting experience and all of us were thoroughly impressed and excited!
We were also lucky enough to get to visit a few wineries which gave us a good idea of the flare of the industry. Many, many, many years ago I visited Walla Walla Washington and the tasting room scene was not exactly on point yet. There were the occasional beautiful estate properties with lux tasting rooms, but most were simple and straight forward with a few being in the winery itself. One in particular had the winemakers in overalls serving on a plank of board over 2 sawhorses. None of that matters if the wine is excellent. But there is a certain look that screams, this is good enough, and good enough isn't that great. It reflects poorly on the effort put into the wines. All burgeoning areas have these types of wineries, it is to be expected, but it is also really exciting to find those gems that are looking at the entire picture and going for it. Attention to detail does make a difference and does reflect on your winemaking. Those guys in overalls serving on a plank of board didn't need a fancy tasting room to make their message clear. They were out in the field tending vines and stopped, got off the tractor to come in, and proudly serve us wines. This is a detail that is appreciated, it shows they care even if it isn't fancy. The tasting room that looks like it fell out of a Temu ad, makes you curious about what corners they are cutting in the winemaking too. I can happily report most of the wineries were putting a lot of thought behind their tasting rooms.
I was also impressed that there were stand out wines at all of the wineries we had the pleasure to visit and experience at the lavish judges' dinner. Of those I have to highlight Sharrott Winery's Cab Franc and their Bellview Brut Pet Nat NV (those of you that know how I feel about Pet Nat will understand just what a compliment it is for me to recommend this wine), Cedar Rose Vineyard's Silica white blend and their Blaufrankisch, William Heritage Winery's Pinot Blanc and their Limited Release Proprietary Red, and Bellview Winery's Gruner Veltliner and their Viognier were all very good. I can confidently suggest you explore each winery's list to see what fits your palate, but if you want to order blindly, you may take my suggestions, I think you'll be very happy with them.
As a professional wine judge it is important that you know I recommend the following 2 wineries not out of personal taste, but because they are showing excellence in their craft. Those wineries are Auburn Road Vineyards & Winery and White Horse Winery. I also really love a well made wine that shows place while expressing the grape and the skilled hand of the winemaker so in that way I guess they are ALSO to my personal taste.
Auburn Road is located on a piece of idyllic wooded property. You arrive at their charming and beautiful tasting room, welcomed by the tidy vineyard and tempting outside patio. We had our tasting under a vine covered pergola. Seated at the large wood table, a thin piece of white linen pulled down the length of it, cheese plates with warm from the oven flat bread perfectly plated were strategically placed making this experience a very shabby chic, Instagram moment vibe I absolutely loved. Husband and wife team, Scott and Jules Donnini are warm and welcoming and clearly passionate about what they do. Scott is a natural frontman with an easy nature and friendly smile. His wife, the winemaker, exudes confidence and knowledge despite the obvious worry on her face as she pours her wines for an intimidating group of know-it-alls. She doesn't need to worry, they are fantastic wines. We start off with a methode champenoise sparkling Gruner Veltliner that made 12 judges heads pop up from their glasses all at once, wide eyed, and gawk at each other. Words didn't need to be said, we were all in agreement, WTH was this?!? Jules quickly started to explain her choices and what she thought she needed to work on for the future vintages. Almost simultaneously we all started to interject, don't do anything different (well maybe enhance the bubbles as she mentioned she wanted to do), this wine is incredible! Beautiful minerality and balance while giving the most perfect varietal expression and lightly yeasty bouquet making this bubbly my new obsession. Their traditional blend sparkling was also brilliant. It could easily be mistaken for a true Champagne. The tasting continued with wine after wine showing to be really impressive and crafted with skill and intention.
My other super stand out, White Horse Winery, is an oasis of park like beauty. The path that leads you to the tasting room winds through lush gardens onto a big wooden deck. It is truly difficult to leave this incredible garden delight to venture inside. The grand open inside focuses you toward a giant square bar in the center. I had the pleasure of sitting with winery Owner BJ Vinton and Bordeaux born and raised winemaker Edward Sparks at the judges' dinner the night before so I had a leg up on the other judges having had the opportunity to grill them privately for 3 hours. The synopsis is that BJ had a vision, he was able to bring in an old friend who is an incredibly talented winemaker, and bam! You have magic in the bottle. The Albariño is fresh with herbal notes and light citrus. It is so clean yet expressive, like all of their wines, but also bright and straightforward. They make excellent whites wines, but the reds, oh mama, there is where I fell in love. In particular I loved the Syrah, which was elegant and nuanced, as well as the Painted Red Bordeaux like blend that had well yielded power and grace.
My take away on New Jersey wines is that these are winemakers that came to play and are not messing around. Across the board I was truly impressed by their Cab Francs and surprisingly floored by everyone's Chardonnays! While they want to hang their hat on the ability to make delicious wines from the Chambourcin grape (they are spot on with their marketing genius of the Couer d' Est blends uniquely made by each winery, but always showcasing Chabourcin), it is the Chardonnays I think that will bring the lime light their way. As the weekend drew to a close, the slogan "New Jersey Wines; We Did it Our Way" took root. A reference to New Jersey native Frank Sinatra's song My Way, this tagline seemed to sum up the energy and determination of this clever wine region. All that is left to say is watch out world, New Jersey Wine is comin to getcha!